A ragged, deteriorating grass bag turns the simple task of mowing into a frustrating, inefficient mess. When the collection system fails, grass clippings scatter everywhere, and reduced airflow dramatically compromises your Toro mower’s performance.
Finding the right replacement is critical for maintaining yard cleanliness and efficiency, but navigating the options—from genuine OEM parts to reliable aftermarket bundles—can be challenging.
We have analyzed the top-rated choices based on material durability, perfect fitment, user satisfaction, and overall value across various price points.
Whether you own a classic Recycler or a newer Flex-Force model, this guide will help you select the ideal bag to restore seamless operation and keep your lawn looking sharp.
1. Niahm 115-4664 Grass Bag Compatible with Toro – Best Budget Friendly
Revitalize your Toro mower economically with the Niahm 115-4664 replacement grass bag. This product’s primary appeal is its exceptional affordability, providing a quick and easy solution when your original bag tears.
Constructed from a reinforced polyester fabric, it functions as a highly tear-resistant aftermarket alternative designed to slide onto your existing original Toro frame with a snug, secure fit.
It delivers an unbeatable economic advantage over premium-priced OEM options, effectively collecting clippings from damp grass to dry leaves without requiring a costly full assembly.
It is a highly functional choice for the DIY homeowner who needs a reliable collection fabric but already possesses an intact metal frame. This bag restores collection capabilities instantly, saving you frustration and money.
Best For: Homeowners seeking maximum cost savings with an existing, undamaged frame for specific 22-inch Recycler models (e.g., xt675 59307 22″ Mower 2009).
Key Specs:
- Part Number: 115-4664
- Material: Reinforced polyester
- Includes Frame: No
- Compatibility: Toro Mower xt675 59307 22″ Mower 2009
Pros
- Highly Affordable
- Tear-Resistant fabric
- Wide Compatibility
- Quick, easy fix
- Dramatic cost savings
Cons
- Frame Not Included
- Aftermarket quality varies
- No OEM material guarantee
2. 2 x 115-4673 Bags & Frame Kit – Best Value Bundle
This unbeatable aftermarket package delivers exceptional long-term value and preparedness, especially beneficial for frequent or heavy-duty users.
This bundle brilliantly addresses the need for both immediate replacement and future wear by including a complete replacement frame assembly and a second, spare grass bag.
The 114-2679-03 frame is designed to fit a wide selection of 22″ Recycler mowers, functioning just like the original hardware. The two included 115-4673 bags attach securely, ready for multiple seasons of demanding work.
This kit is a straightforward swap for the old unit, providing robust collection capabilities for models like the 20332 and 20330.
It’s the ideal pragmatic choice, prioritizing overall economy and preventing downtime due to inevitable rips or tears.
Best For: Frequent users, commercial operators, or homeowners with large properties who prioritize preparedness and need a full assembly replacement with a guaranteed spare.
Key Specs:
- Part Numbers: 115-4673, 114-2679-03
- Includes: 2 x Grass Catcher Bag & 1 x Frame Kit
- Compatibility: 20330, 20332, 20333, 20332C (2016-2019)
Pros
- Excellent Value bundle
- Spare Bag Included
- Complete Kit assembly
- Wide Compatibility coverage
- Prioritizes long-term preparedness
Cons
- Higher Initial Cost
- Aftermarket Parts used
- Must check owner’s manual
3. Toro Genuine OEM 139-5471 Grass Bag – Best for Newer Models
For owners of newer Toro equipment, the Toro Genuine OEM 139-5471 Grass Bag provides the specified, factory-correct replacement engineered for modern machines.
This genuine bag ensures that the mower maintains its peak performance and specific airflow characteristics, crucial for efficient collection in models like the Flex-Force Power Recycler 22.
As a non-generic replacement, it attaches flawlessly to the newer frames, handling the powerful output of these mowers without undue strain on the engine.
Its value lies in its precise application, assuring owners that they are maintaining factory specifications rather than risking an ill-fitting aftermarket product.
This is a targeted, bag-only replacement designed for the discerning owner who accepts the premium cost for guaranteed OEM quality and perfect fitment.
Best For: Owners of recent 22-inch Recycler and Flex-Force mowers (e.g., 21462, 21468) who demand factory specifications and optimal performance.
Key Specs:
- Part Number: 139-5471
- Product Type: Grass Bag (bag only)
- Compatibility: Recycler 22 Rear Bagger, Flex-Force Power Recycler 22/21
Pros
- OEM Quality standard
- Fits Newer Models perfectly
- Optimized Airflow design
- Factory-Spec Fit assured
- Maintains peak performance
Cons
- Frame Not Included
- Premium Cost required
- Narrow Compatibility range
4. Wmmeting Grass Bag Fit for Toro 22in – Best Fit for 20332 Models
The Wmmeting grass bag is a highly cost-effective aftermarket solution focused specifically on some of Toro’s most popular 22-inch Recycler models, particularly the 20332 lineup.
This focused compatibility eliminates the compatibility guesswork that often plagues third-party parts for owners of these specific machines (including 20337 and 20340).
The bag fits snugly onto the original equipment frame, instantly restoring bagging functionality. While focused on a low price point, the material is competent for handling standard residential clipping and leaf collection.
This strictly replacement bag is the ideal choice for users prioritizing simplicity, confirmed fitment, and the lowest possible price to get their machine back into working order.
Best For: Budget-conscious owners of highly specific, popular 22-inch Recycler models (e.g., 20332, 20333) needing a confirmed fit without brand premium.
Key Specs:
- Lawn Mower Size: 22in
- Product Type: Grass Bag
- Compatibility: Toro 22in Models (e.g., 20332, 20332C, 20337, 20376)
Pros
- Very Affordable price
- Model-Specific Fit promised
- Simple Replacement process
- Instantly restores function
- Eliminates fit guesswork
Cons
- Aftermarket Durability risk
- Frame Not Included
- Focused compatibility promise
5. Replacement Grass Bag 115-4664 Compatible Toro – Best Mid-Range Aftermarket
This reliable grass bag serves as a solid aftermarket substitute for the extremely common OEM part 115-4664, offering a versatile and functional fix for a huge array of Toro 22-inch Recycler mowers.
Engineered to fit models such as the 20330 and 20370, this product is a practical choice for addressing a ripped or rotted bag without significant financial outlay.
The bag attaches to the mower’s original frame without hassle, creating a secure seal that prevents dust and clippings from escaping the collection system.
The fabric is substantial enough for routine mowing tasks and stands up well to the suction forces within the deck.
This option is designed for the practical homeowner seeking a dependable, no-frills part that focuses purely on restoring efficient bagging capability.
Best For: Practical users seeking a reliable, functional aftermarket bag for older, widely compatible 22-inch Recycler models whose original frame is robust.
Key Specs:
- Part Number: 115-4664
- Includes: One bag only (without frame)
- Compatibility: Toro xt675 59307 22″ Recycler (e.g., 20330, 20370, 20377)
Pros
- Solid Value proposition
- Wide Compatibility range
- Direct Replacement functionality
- Secure seal prevents leaks
- Fabric feels substantial
Cons
- Frame Not Included
- Aftermarket Quality level
- Requires frame integrity
6. Genuine OEM Toro 131-4556 Bag & Frame – Best Overall
As a genuine OEM complete kit, the Toro 131-4556 assembly represents the definitive choice for comprehensive replacement, delivering a perfect factory fit right out of the box.
Unlike bag-only options, this solution includes the necessary wire frame, guaranteeing stable bag support and optimized airflow from the first use.
This package is engineered to exact factory specifications, eliminating potential quality issues found in some aftermarket alternatives and ensuring reliable performance.
For users whose original frame is bent, rusted, or missing entirely, investing in this factory assembly minimizes installation hassle and maximizes longevity and collection efficiency. It provides a seamless, durable restoration of your mower’s bagging system.
Best For: Users prioritizing guaranteed factory longevity, seeking reliable performance, or those whose original frame is damaged, rusted, or completely missing.
Key Specs:
- Includes: Bag and Frame
- Product Type: Genuine OEM
- Compatibility (Examples): 20355, 20960, 20353
Pros
- Perfect factory fit
- Includes sturdy frame
- Maximum durability assurance
- Ensures optimized airflow
- Reliable performance guarantee
Cons
- Highest cost option
- Single bag included
- Compatibility is less broad
7. Toro Part # 115-4664 Grass Bag – Best Genuine OEM Only
This genuine OEM bag is the factory standard replacement for many widely compatible 22-inch Recycler models.
Opting for the official Toro Part # 115-4664 means investing in guaranteed quality, material assurance, and an exact match to the original equipment design.
While aftermarket bags compete heavily on price, this specific Toro-branded item provides the unwavering confidence of lasting construction and maintains the proper collection aerodynamics of your machine.
It is the essential targeted upgrade for owners of compatible models whose frames remain in serviceable condition but who demand the superior resilience and specific construction of a genuine cloth bag over budget third-party options.
Best For: Owners of older, compatible Toro models (e.g., 20330, 20331) who require OEM material quality but whose existing frame is still fully functional and robust.
Key Specs:
- Part Number: 115-4664
- Product Type: Genuine OEM Cloth Bag
- Includes Frame: No
Pros
- Genuine factory quality
- Superior material assurance
- Precise aerodynamic fit
- Durable cloth construction
- Maintains collection efficiency
Cons
- Premium cost factor
- Frame must be reused
- Less budget-friendly choice
How to Choose the Right Replacement Bag for Your Toro Lawn Mower
Correct Model Compatibility
Always verify compatibility using your specific Toro mower model and serial number. The wrong fit compromises the seal under the deck, leading to poor suction and clippings blowing out.
Check your owner’s manual or cross-reference the model number to confirm the correct part number (like 115-4664 or 139-5471) to ensure efficient collection and easy installation.
OEM vs. Aftermarket Bags
Decide between genuine Toro OEM bags and compatible aftermarket versions. OEM options ensure a perfect fit and reliable, long-lasting performance but come at a higher cost.
Aftermarket bags (like Niahm or Wmmeting) offer budget-friendly alternatives; however, look closely for reinforced stitching and durable fabric construction to minimize variation in quality.
Bag Only vs. Bag & Frame Kit
If your metal frame is undamaged and functional, a bag-only replacement is the cost-effective choice.
If the frame is bent, rusted, or missing entirely, a bag and frame kit (such as the 2 x 115-4673 bundle) offers superior value. A new frame improves bag support and helps restore optimal airflow and bagging efficiency.
Material and Durability
Prioritize bags made from heavy-duty, tear-resistant polyester or laminated fabric. Reinforced seams and UV-resistant materials are essential features.
These qualities ensure the bag withstands abrasive wet clippings and harsh sun exposure, significantly extending the product’s functional lifespan and preventing early failure