Worn or damaged lawn mower wheels are more than just an inconvenience—they severely impact cutting precision, leading to frustrating issues like uneven grass height, deck scalping, and dramatically increased pushing effort.
For Craftsman mower owners, replacing faulty wheels is essential to maintain proper deck alignment and ensure smooth, efficient operation.
Using incompatible replacements can lead to wobbling, poor traction, and unnecessary strain on your drive system.
To help you restore your machine’s performance, we analyzed top options, combining OEM specifications with real-world user feedback to identify the most dependable choices.
Whether you need rugged rear wheels for a self-propelled model or reliable front casters for a push mower, here are our top picks confirmed for seamless installation and guaranteed long-term durability.
1. CRAFTSMAN 8-Inch FWD Wheel (CMXGZAM325070) – Best Overall
The CRAFTSMAN 8-Inch FWD Wheel (CMXGZAM325070) stands out as the best overall replacement option, engineered specifically to solve the frustrating problem of lost traction on difficult lawns.
Its standout feature is the aggressive tread pattern, designed to effectively bite into turf, grass, and damp hills where standard wheels often slip.
This wheel is considered an upgrade over simple replacements due to its durable construction, featuring a 1.25-inch oil-impregnated copper steel bushing that guarantees a smoother, more durable rotation compared to typical plastic hubs.
These 8-inch front-wheel-drive replacements significantly reduce slippage when navigating inclines or making tight turns, proving their robustness.
They are compatible with Craftsman walk-behind mowers, snow blowers, and edgers, proving their versatility across different types of equipment and seasons.
The CMXGZAM325070 is the ideal choice for homeowners demanding uncompromising traction and specialized, lasting performance.
- Key Features:
- Aggressive tread pattern
- Oil-impregnated copper steel bushing
- 8-inch diameter
- Designed for FWD walk-behind mowers, snow blowers, and edgers
- Pros:
- Superior grip and aggressive traction
- Excellent durability due to the copper bushing
- OEM quality ensures precise fitment
- Transforms handling on uneven terrain
- Cons:
- Slightly heavier than plastic options
- Less smooth when used on perfectly flat pavement
2. 583719501 Front Drive Wheels – Best Budget Friendly
The 583719501 Front Drive Wheels offer an exceptional balance of performance and compatibility, making them the best budget-friendly choice for repairing self-propelled mowers with worn-out drive systems.
This two-pack is crucial for restoring self-propel functionality instantly, as the design precisely integrates 53 gear teeth that ensure a perfect mesh with the mower’s drive mechanism.
Constructed from a high-density plastic and premium rubber composite, these wheels are built to address common failures like stripped original parts without requiring a hefty investment.
They boast wide compatibility, fitting various models from Husqvarna, Poulan, Roper, Sears/Craftsman, and Weedeater, and they replace numerous part numbers, including 532402657 and 194231X460.
The 8-inch diameter and 1-3/4-inch width perfectly match OEM specifications, ensuring consistent traction and preventing operational wobble.
This set provides reliable, practical repair value, prioritizing the restoration of original functionality for a vast number of self-propelled models.
- Key Features:
- Integrated 53 gear teeth
- 8-inch diameter and 1-3/4-inch width
- High-density plastic and premium rubber material
- Wide compatibility across multiple brands (Craftsman, Husqvarna, Poulan)
- Pros:
- Excellent value and accessible price point
- Immediately restores self-propel function
- Very easy and straightforward installation
- Replicates original performance reliably
- Cons:
- Standard, non-aggressive tread pattern
- Primary construction includes plastic components
3. 490-324-0002 Rear Wheels – Best for Rear Replacement
The 490-324-0002 Rear Wheels are a heavy-duty, oversized solution, specifically designed for robust rear replacement on larger walk-behind mowers.
Their defining characteristic is the solid, puncture-proof construction, effectively eliminating the risk of flats associated with air-filled or weaker plastic tires.
The large 12-inch diameter provides superior stability and delivers a significantly smoother ride, especially over bumpy or uneven terrain, making yard work less strenuous.
Featuring a bar tread pattern, these 12-inch by 1.7-inch wheels offer dependable traction without being overly aggressive on the turf.
Each wheel features a robust 50 lb. load rating, confirming its durability and capability to handle the weight of heavier mower models from brands including Craftsman, Honda, and Husqvarna.
The installation is simplified, as the package includes essential hardware like plastic spacers and metal washers, allowing for a customized fit on various axle setups. This set provides foundational stability and durability for the entire machine.
- Key Features:
- Puncture-proof, durable solid construction
- Large 12″ x 1.7″ size
- 50 lb. load rating for heavy models
- Includes back wheels, spacers, and metal washers
- Pros:
- Offers superior stability and smoother ride
- Built for endurance and heavy-duty use
- Includes necessary hardware for customized fitment
- Excellent for larger walk-behind mowers
- Cons:
- Specifically designed only for the rear axle
- Uses a simple bar tread design
4. Budrash 180775 Front Wheels – Best for Gear-Driven Mowers
Engineered to revitalize gear-driven mowers, the Budrash 180775 Front Wheels are a precision replacement for many popular models, serving as the best choice for this mower type.
The core feature is the 53-tooth gear integrated into the hub, which seamlessly engages with the self-propel mechanism to restore power instantly.
This two-pack specifically remedies the common problem of stripped plastic gears, transforming a difficult-to-push machine back into an effortless self-propelled mower.
The 8 x 2-inch dimensions and 1/2-inch bore size are engineered as an exact match for compatible Craftsman 917 series mowers.
The hub’s 1-9/16-inch length ensures a snug fit on the axle, eliminating the undesirable wheel wobble often caused by worn-out original parts. The black rubber tread provides reliable, everyday traction across standard mowing conditions.
These wheels are highly compatible with models from Craftsman, Snapper, Husqvarna, and Poulan Pro, offering a direct and dependable fix that rivals comparable gear-driven replacements.
- Key Features:
- Critical 53 gear teeth for drive restoration
- 8 x 2″ wheel size with 1/2″ bore
- Durable black rubber tread
- Replaces multiple OEM numbers (e.g., 180775, 180773)
- Pros:
- Restores the self-propel drive power effectively
- Precise gear design ensures seamless engagement
- Wide model compatibility among gear-driven mowers
- Easy and quick installation process
- Cons:
- The gear hub construction uses plastic
- Provides only standard, non-aggressive traction
5. 634-05040 Wheel Assembly – Best for Self-Propelled Mowers
The 634-05040 Wheel Assembly is the definitive choice for self-propelled mowers, offering a precision-engineered solution for owners of specific modern Craftsman, Cub Cadet, and MTD mowers.
These wheels function as a direct OEM replacement, guaranteeing flawless compatibility and eliminating the guesswork associated with generic parts.
Their primary benefit is restoring the smooth, stable operation of a 21-inch self-propelled mower to the manufacturer’s intended standard, quickly resolving issues like poor fitment or wobbling.
The 8-inch wheels slide onto the axle of compatible models, such as the Craftsman M215, with factory-level precision, providing a secure and solid assembly.
Once mounted, the assembly delivers a smooth, consistent roll that noticeably enhances the mower’s overall maneuverability.
While they may sacrifice broad applicability compared to universal options, the 634-05040 wheels guarantee a perfect fit and finish for their targeted list of models, ensuring original performance and stability.
Installation is straightforward, typically involving prying off the cover, loosening the nut, sliding the wheel on, and tightening.
- Key Features:
- Direct OEM replacement (MTD/Cub Cadet 634-05040)
- 8-inch diameter wheel assembly
- Specifically engineered for 21-inch self-propelled mowers
- Designed to restore stability and fit
- Pros:
- Guaranteed perfect model-specific fit
- Restores factory-level stability and handling
- Easy installation process
- Flawless compatibility avoids installation headaches
- Cons:
- Compatibility is limited to specific models (e.g., Cub Cadet, MTD Gold)
- Features a standard, non-upgraded tread design
6. 72-108 Universal Lawn Wheels – Best Universal Fit
The 72-108 Universal Lawn Wheels from Oregon are the ultimate utility player, earning the title of Best Universal Fit due to their incredibly broad compatibility.
These 8-inch diameter wheels are designed to fit far beyond just Craftsman and MTD mowers, also serving as reliable replacements for equipment like Weber BBQ grills, Radio Flyer wagons, and hand trucks.
This adaptability makes the 72-108 a practical item for general home and garden equipment repairs. They feature a standard 1/2-inch bore and 1-3/8-inch hub length, allowing them to fit a wide array of axles often with minimal modification required.
The diamond tread pattern offers a functional balance of grip and low rolling resistance. Although the construction relies on standard plastic, it is sufficiently durable for light-to-medium duty applications on mowers and carts.
The 72-108 wheels roll smoothly on both hard surfaces and grass, offering a significant upgrade in grip over severely worn tires.
This option is a pragmatic, multi-purpose replacement, offering affordability and far greater flexibility than model-specific solutions.
- Key Features:
- Extremely broad compatibility (Craftsman, AYP, Weber BBQ)
- 8″ diameter
- Standard 1/2-inch bore and 1-3/8-inch hub length
- Plastic and rubber construction with diamond tread
- Pros:
- Highly versatile for multi-equipment use
- Excellent value and affordability
- Easy installation, often requiring just one wrench
- Reliable, no-fuss solution for general repairs
- Cons:
- Basic plastic hub construction
- Tread pattern is non-aggressive
7. 7 Inch Push Mower Wheels – Best for Small Mowers
The 7 Inch Push Mower Wheels are specialized, non-driven replacements designed for manual push mowers and various smaller equipment, offering the ideal solution for lighter machines.
These wheels are simpler than geared front or large rear-drive assemblies. They are typically constructed from high-quality PU plastic, which makes them light, rust-proof, and suitable for lighter mowers or flat terrains.
While specific details vary by brand, these 7-inch options are categorized as having low price/value and are wear-resistant with a strong grip suitable for standard push mower operation.
When selecting a replacement, it is crucial to match the 7-inch diameter to ensure the correct mower deck height is maintained.
Because push mower wheels do not feature the complex gear teeth required for self-propelled systems, they focus on durability and low rolling resistance.
They often come as kits, including necessary hardware such as bolts and nuts, ensuring an easy installation onto most standard push mower axles.
Choosing these smaller wheels helps restore smooth rolling capability and keeps the machine running efficiently for years to come.
- Key Features:
- 7-inch diameter
- Non-driven wheel design
- High-quality PU plastic construction
- Wear-resistant material
- Pros:
- Ideal for light-duty manual push mowers
- Lighter weight and rust-proof
- Excellent choice for flat terrain
- Strong grip designed for standard use
- Cons:
- Not suitable for self-propelled systems
- Less shock absorption than rubber tires
How to Choose the Right Replacement Craftsman Lawn Mower Wheels: A Detailed Buying Guide
Choosing the correct replacement Craftsman lawn mower wheels requires matching the wheel to your mower’s specifications, drive system, and existing hardware. Selecting the wrong wheel can lead to poor performance, instability, or even damage to your machine.
1. Match the Wheel Type to the Drive System
Not all mower wheels are interchangeable; they are categorized based on their function:
- Front Drive Wheels: These are designed specifically for self-propelled mowers and include gear teeth that engage directly with the drive mechanism (e.g., CRAFTSMAN 8-Inch FWD or Budrash 180775).
- Rear Wheels: These are typically larger in diameter (often 12-inch, like the 490-324-0002) and are designed to support more weight, making them ideal for heavier rear-wheel-drive models.
- Push Mower Wheels: These are simpler, non-driven wheels used exclusively on manual push mowers or small, non-motorized equipment (often 7-inch models).
2. Verify Compatibility and Part Numbers
Always verify your mower’s model number and the original part number before making a purchase.
- Use OEM replacement numbers (like 583719501 or 634-05040) to guarantee a precise fit.
- While many wheels fit multiple brands (including Husqvarna or MTD), even slight differences in the hub or bore size can prevent proper installation. Consult your owner’s manual or the manufacturer’s website to find the correct OEM number.
3. Pay Attention to Critical Dimensions
Small measurement discrepancies are critical differentiators that affect stability and performance.
- Diameter: This measurement (typically 7” or 8” for front wheels, 12” for rear) must match the original to maintain the mower deck height and prevent scalping.
- Bore Size: This size (usually 1/2”) must fit snugly onto the axle.
- Hub Offset and Width: Incorrect specifications here can cause the wheel to wobble, or worse, interfere with the mower deck itself.
4. Choose Durable Materials and Tread Design
The materials determine longevity and traction in different environments:
- Rubber Tires with aggressive treads (like the CRAFTSMAN FWD Wheel) offer superior traction and better shock absorption, making them ideal for challenging or uneven lawns.
- Plastic or PU Wheels (like the 72-108 Universal) are lighter and rust-proof. They are better suited for lighter mowers or working exclusively on flat terrain.
- For extended life, look for quality components like oil-impregnated bushings or nylon hubs, which significantly reduce friction.
5. Installation and Included Hardware
Most replacements are designed to bolt on using basic tools. Look for kits that include essential hardware such as spacers, washers, or bolts (like the 490-324-0002 set).
This inclusion reduces guesswork and ensures the wheels are securely mounted. If your mower uses a snap-on cover (as referenced for the 634-05040), ensure the new wheel is designed to support that feature.